Best & Worst Maps of all
time!
At a Committee get-together earlier this year
aspiring members were invited to enter the "rogaine test".
Crossing a very narrow pole stretched across a ‘creek’ (swimming
pool). We are pleased to report that all passed with flying colours
although some on second attempt and some seemed more balanced after
a few drinks.
On the same occasion billed as a "Map
Party" guests were invited to bring along their best and worst
maps. Some of the entrants were as follows:
Best:
Blue Mountains and Burragorang 1937, 2 miles: 1
inch, huge and hand drawn, showing a now long closed road from
Wentworth Falls to Warragamba River (no dam in those days).
Graeme Cooper.
Middle Earth,The Lord of the Rings, JRR Tolkein,
Watch out for Mirkwood and Mordor.
Mike Hotchkis.
Cross Your Rubicon’ 50 Hour Endurogaine Cathedral
SF/Goulburn Valley/Mt Torbreck, Victoria. Featured bonus points for
being first up remote peaks on the far corners of the map. Not too
many participants!
Mike Hotchkis.
Dudh Kosi, down stream from Namche Bazaar and the
Solu Khumbu region of Nepal. 1:50,000, 40m contours, beautifully
produced and shaded by Erwin Shneider. Shows every dwelling. One of
a series of the Everest region.
Alan Mansfield.
Stirling Range National Park, WA, 1st ed 1966, 3rd
1972, GA Dean, 1:63,360 (1 inch:1 mile). The first map of the
Stirling Range, finely drafted with selected contours and
information for bushwalkers.
Julian Ledger.
Worst:
Amadeus, Central Australia, 1:250,000, in one part
of the map, comfortably large enough to hold a 24 hour rogaine,
there are absolutely no details, no contours and nothing but grid
lines.
Greame Cooper.
Murrumbo, Hunter Valley, 24 hr rogaine in 1989,
1:37,500, map was a colour photocopy of a copy and some detail
dropped out. Alignment problems with map pieces and one hill not
marked at all on base map.
Trevor Gollan.
Solomon's Throne, 4th World Rogaine Championships,
New Zealand, Jan 2000. 1:50,000, Heavy shading on the map made
reading tricky, area too steep! Setting could have been done to
allow for more route choice.
Richard Sage
Beechworth, 1st World Rogaining Championships, 1992,
1:50,000, massive map with approx 500sq.km, large distances between
controls, mostly tracks. Not to mention rain, blackberries and mine
shafts!
Julian Ledger.
Kangaroo Flat on Hastings River near Port Macquarie.
Got lost due to significant topographical features not shown.
Returned later to use new edition and had not been corrected.
Andrew Pope.
Quilty's Mountain, Australian Rogaining
Championships, 1995 in Morton National Park. 1:25,000. Very thick
vegetation and then monsoon conditions. Only contacted map on one
side and eventually it disintegrated leaving map features transposed
onto the contact.
Julian Ledger.
Compiled by Julian Ledger
|